Rhody Trader

John Stuart Mills introduced me to the term “tyranny of the majority” in his essay On Liberty. Basically, that means a group using its majority position to oppress a minority group in some fashion. A classic example in the US is the case of blacks being oppressed by the white majority.

Of course Mills wasn’t the first to introduce the concept. I just happened to read it first in his work. Plato, Aristotle, Madison, and Tocqueville (I’m sure among others), all addressed the issue as well in their discussions of democratic government.

I bring this up because we’re seeing the tyranny of the majority in glaring fashion in Congress right now with the healthcare legislation. Among the plans to pay for the proposed bill is to add a surtax to those who’s earnings exceed certain threshold levels. Why? It pretty much comes down to “because we can”.

This statement was made by answers.com in the definition of tryanny of the majority:

The main danger that worried Aristotle, Madison, and Mill alike was that the majority poor citizenry would vote for confiscatory legislation at the expense of the rich minority. For whatever reason, this has never happened.

Hmmmm….They might need to change that comment before too long.

Trackback URI |